I don’t know, Wong Kar Wai. I don’t know if it was such a good idea to cast Norah Jones as the main character in your film. A beautiful singing voice and perfect lips that look sexy in a close-up when they’re covered in ice cream do not a lead actor make. She wasn’t grating (not for me, anyway—Ross, on the other hand, turned to me after the credits started rolling, shook his head, and said “I can’t stand Norah Jones. Everything she said sounded like it was coming out of the mouth of a Valley girl.”), but she wasn’t great. And I don’t know why you decided to confine Jude Law, who is an experienced and capable actor, to the tiny set of his cafĂ© and give him no discernible personality whatsoever beyond his ability to bake, his incredible niceness, and his obsession with finding a girl who clearly doesn’t want to be found (yet).
I forgive you for Natalie Portman, because she was honestly much, much more convincing than I had imagined she would be as a peroxided gambler with a sad past, a sassy tongue, and a sweet streak—but did you really have to make her put on an accent on top of all that makeup? And I thank you for David Strathairn, whose alcoholic, stalker-ex-husband character was the only one I really believed in for a moment and really felt for, and whose end was as fitting as it was inevitable. The Otis Redding that you kept playing during those scenes at the bar was pretty wonderful, too.
I don’t know. You can’t help but make a gorgeous movie, and you have such a deft hand with interweaving periods of silence and sound; and the story of Jeremy and Elizabeth is engaging enough, as romances go—I just don’t understand why you wanted to make a romance, a straight romance, anyway. There was a dark heart missing from the sweet dessert of My Blueberry Nights that I wanted to taste and just wasn’t there.