Ross and I ventured out in the quiet snow yesterday at 9pm to see Vicky Christina Barcelona at DocFilms—the cruel season and the fall of night conspiring to make the movie’s verdant setting, steeped in sunlight, seem even more startlingly unreal than Woody must have wanted it to. In case you haven’t seen it, here’s the deal: Two absurdly gorgeous twenty-something Americans spend a summer in Barcelona, where they meet a passionate Spanish painter who succeeds in seducing both of them (separately, though he’d rather it were together) and become embroiled in the messy tangle of his relationship with his crazy-beautiful ex-wife, who has a murderous streak when in the heat of romantic jealousy.
Anya wrote a review of Vicky Christina in which she calls it a “coy, shy longing for a fairy-tale vision of love,” and I’ll start by saying that I agree it’s supposed to evoke a fairy tale, which is one reason for the intrusive narrative voice that runs all along the film’s edges like a gilt frame. I don’t, however, think the movie is either coy or shy, and I definitely don’t think it longs for a fairy-tale vision of love.
Everyone in the film has an incomplete and somewhat warped idea of what love is; no one is capable of learning or growing. Where affairs of the heart are concerned, Christina—impulsive, blonde, artistic but not very good at it—says things like, “I’ll go to your room, but… you have to seduce me.” Vicky—pragmatic, brunette, scholarly but not very good at it—says things like, “If you would care to join us for some recognized form of social interaction, like a drink, then we’d be fine, but otherwise, I think you should try offering [your seductive Spanish charms] to some other table.” Juan Antonio—the painter—says things like, “Life is short. Life is dull. Life is full of pain. And [having a threesome with a complete stranger] is a chance for something special.” Maria Elena—the murderous ex-wife—says things like, “Our love is forever, but it just doesn’t work. That’s why it will always be romantic. Because it cannot be complete.”
And just in case you aren’t capable of realizing on your own how the simple act of pursuing their earnest beliefs to their logical ends makes a fool out of each of these characters, the narrator (invisible, but horribly smug) is continually engaged in a kind of gentle mockery of them: “She saw herself more a European soul, in tune with the thinkers and artists she felt expressed her tragic, romantic, freethinking view of life.”
No one is capable of learning, growing, or changing: everyone’s fate is inevitable from the first, and no one receives a happy ending, because no one deserves one. Where Anya thinks of the film as a failed fairy tale in which true love is idealized, but ultimately shown to be unattainable, I think of it as an anti-romance, in which the idea of true love has sticks poked into it—but very tenderly—from every possible angle.
Yet by the end of the movie you feel that very little harm has been done, and that’s largely because the characters are so utterly ridiculous that it’s hard to take them seriously. It is, however, very easy to enjoy watching them, since they are all very, very pretty. And for that reason, quite despite myself, I liked Vicky Christina Barcelona from beginning to end.